Wednesday, October 15, 2014

Ridiculous Test Question from Houghton Mifflin Harcourt

Honestly, I want to know.  Who is writing this stuff?

8th grade pre-algebra

OK, so I read this several times and finally understood what they wanted.  Keep in mind, this was a "no calculator" test.  

I'll explain:  every square root has two answers, one positive and one negative.  

For example, √25 = ±5, because (-5) x (-5) also equals 25.  

So, without a calculator (why, and why would anyone have to calculate this anyway?) the students needed to find a number with a square root of about 1/2 of 5.3, so that the difference between the positive square root and the negative square root equals about 5.3.  

One of the most pointless questions I've seen to date.


No comments:

Post a Comment